CINCINNATI (AP/WCMH) – A University of Cincinnati officer who shot a motorist during a traffic stop over a missing front license plate was indicted Wednesday on a murder charge, with a prosecutor saying the officer “purposely killed him” and “should never have been a police officer.”
Hamilton County Prosecutor Joe Deters announced the grand jury indictment at a news conference to discuss developments in the investigation into the July 19 shooting of 43-year-old motorist Samuel DuBose by Officer Ray Tensing.
This is a case absolutely striking a nerve in this city.
Large crowds filled downtown streets Wednesday night — many people holding signs, like license plates that read “I AM SAM.”
The people here heard an indictment — they told NBC4 all they want is a conviction.
It started as a rally in the rain.
It turned in to a rally of hundreds.
On the courthouse steps in Hamilton County — Samuel DuBose’s friends were here.
His daughter, Teaila Williams, said she forgave Officer Tensing.
“I forgive him because I feel like if he can go back and redo this, I feel like he wouldn’t have done it,” she said. “I saw his face today. I feel like he realized he messed up, but it is what it is and he has to face the consequences.”
And, she said, she never expected this sudden end to her father’s life.
“I never thought like he would die by getting shot because I never actually imagined him dying to be honest.”
Dubose’s death was unexpected, sudden, and in the words of so many here it was brutal.
Authorities have said Tensing spotted a car driven by DuBose and missing the front license plate, which is required by Ohio law. They say Tensing stopped the car and a struggle ensued after DuBose refused to provide a driver’s license and get out of the car.
Tensing, 25, has said he was dragged by the car and forced to shoot at DuBose. He fired once, striking DuBose in the head.
But Deters dismissed Tensing’s claim that he was dragged by the car and suggested that he shouldn’t have pulled DuBose over to begin with.
“He fell backward after he shot (DuBose) in the head,” Deters said, adding that it was a “chicken crap” traffic stop.
On footage released from the body-camera video Wednesday, the officer could be heard asking for DuBose’s driver’s license several times with DuBose at one point saying he had one. Later, DuBose said, “But I don’t think I have it on me.”
Tensing asks DuBose to unbuckle his seat belt. About that time Tensing pulls on the door handle, and DuBose puts his hand on the door to keep it closed. Then the video becomes shaky, but a gunshot can be heard and DuBose appears to be slumped in the seat before the car rolls away, coming to stop at a nearby corner.
The University of Cincinnati said it fired Tensing after his indictment. Tensing turned himself in Wednesday afternoon at the Hamilton County Justice Center and was processed on charges of murder and voluntary manslaughter.
Tensing’s attorney, Stewart Mathews, didn’t return phone messages seeking comment after the indictment announcement.
Mathews said earlier Wednesday that he thought an indictment was likely “given the political climate” and comments made by city officials. But Mathews said given the evidence he’s seen, he doesn’t believe there should be an indictment.
DuBose’s death comes amid months of national scrutiny of police dealings with African-Americans, especially those killed by officers. DuBose was black. Tensing is white. Authorities haven’t indicated whether race was a part of the investigation.
Body-camera video of the shooting was also released Wednesday. DuBose’s family had been pressing for its release, and news organizations including The Associated Press had sued Deters to get it released under Ohio open records law, but Deters released it before any ruling had been made.
Deters called the shooting “senseless” and “asinine.”
“He purposely killed him,” Deters said. “He should never have been a police officer.”
The prosecutor also said he thought it was time to reconsider the UC police department’s role.
“I don’t think a university should be in the policing business,” Deters said.
A message for comment was left Wednesday with the police department. The university said earlier this week it plans an independent review of its police department’s policies.
The UC officer made the traffic stop near the university’s main campus, and UC police have said the intersection was within the campus police’s jurisdiction.
The University of Cincinnati on Wednesday closed its main campus in anticipation of grand jury action in the case.
Mark O’Mara, attorney for DuBose’s family, called for a “peaceful and nonaggressive” response from the community after the officer’s indictment. O’Mara said the family wanted a peaceful reaction because “Sam was a peaceful person.”
Tensing has more than five years of experience in law enforcement and has worked as a University of Cincinnati police officer since April 2014, said Jason Goodrich, UC police chief. His annual performance review this April noted that he was extremely strong in the traffic area and maintains control of his weapons and of “situations he is involved in.”
Tensing formerly worked as an officer in the small Cincinnati suburban village of Greenhills.
Deters said when he saw the video of the shooting, he was shocked.
“I feel so sorry for this family and what they lost,” Deters said. “And I feel sorry for the community, too.”
If convicted, Tensing could face up to life in prison.
Associated Press writers Dan Sewell in Cincinnati and Kantele Franko and Mitch Stacy in Columbus contributed to this report.